Topic 1385 of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ): Refusal of bank guarantee and surety bond by the Public Treasury in tax enforcement proceedings.

The Superior Court of Justice (“STJ”) recently concluded the judgment of Repetitive Theme No. 1385, bringing greater clarity to taxpayers disputing tax debts in tax enforcement proceedings. The STJ ruled that the Public Treasury cannot refuse bank guarantees or surety bonds offered to secure the judgment solely on the grounds that the order of preference established in the Tax Enforcement Law was not followed.

The discussion revolves around the interpretation of articles 9 and 11 of the Tax Enforcement Law. Although the law provides a list of preferred assets for seizure, beginning with money, in practice the tax authorities have been rejecting guarantees such as bank guarantees and surety bonds simply because they do not occupy the first place in this order. This stance ended up increasing the cost of tax litigation and, in many cases, requiring the immediate freezing of companies' financial resources.

In analyzing the issue repeatedly, the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) rejected this stricter interpretation. The Court made it clear that the legal order of preference does not authorize the automatic refusal of bank guarantees or surety bonds. These instruments must be accepted whenever they are sufficient, regular, and provided by reputable institutions. For a refusal to occur, the Treasury must demonstrate, concretely, that the guarantee is inadequate, and not merely state that it prefers a cash deposit.

The decision follows the line of previous understandings of the STJ itself, which already recognized bank guarantees and surety bonds as effective means of securing tax executions, with the same practical purpose as judicial deposits.

more publications

266

Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Flávio Dino upheld the implementation of the new constitutional rules on working hours as scheduled for December 16, 2026, and established parameters for the transition from a 44-hour work week to...

279

Provisional Measure No. 1,399/2026, published on November 4, 2026, established the Selective Tax (IS) rates for 2027, effective from February 2, 2027. Instituted by the Tax Reform, the tax will apply to goods...

271

The binding precedent validated the 220 divisor established in the collective bargaining agreement, but it originated from the debate on Topic 1,046 of the Supreme Federal Court (STF), and not from the constitutional change regarding working hours; companies are exposed to the risk of liability for overtime. The binding precedent of...

268

The enactment of the Constitutional Amendment resulting from PEC No. 221/2019, which reduces the maximum work week from 44 to 40 hours and eliminates the 6x1 shift schedule by extending paid weekly rest, consolidates a historical milestone in labor relations...

273

Complementary Law No. 236, published on September 4, 2026, introduced significant changes to the National Tax Code (CTN), especially regarding penalties arising from non-compliance with principal and accessory tax obligations. Among the new provisions, the establishment of... stands out.

269

The TST (Superior Labor Court), in its ruling on Case 215, decided that workers may, exceptionally, file a labor lawsuit in their place of residence, even if the defendant company does not have national size or operations. The decision establishes the precedent that...